Strike Wars
January 20th, 2009 by CorrineAnother round in the epic battle between university admin and CUPE.
University of Toronto students have always found a sense of pride in not being York students. The announcement of a vote in favour of strike action by our teaching assistants caused many students to pause for a moment and wonder if this sense of pride could possibly… maybe… almost be unfounded! An undergrad town hall on collective bargaining with representatives from CUPE 3902 and UTSU answered questions and heard concerns about the potential strike. So stop putting your transfer application for Windsor, McGill or McMaster together: everything is going to be just fine, or so we’ve been told.
Find out more after the jump.
The Facts
- CUPE 3902 represents TAs and course instructors on the all three U of T campuses.
The vast majority of their members are graduate students working towards Masters or Doctorial degrees. - The TAs and course instructors have been without a contract since April 2008.
- The current bargaining process started in July.
- 700 of the 11000 people represented by 3902 voted in favour of a strike.
What exactly do they want?
According to CUPE 3902’s website:
Meaningful childcare assistance for our members to ensure women and families can access education.
An end to the outrageously expensive, private for-profit University Health Insurance Plan (UHIP), currently forced on international students and their families, and a commitment from the employer to cover the premiums in the meantime.
Measures that address ballooning tutorial and lab sizes and thus maintain the quality of education for our students.
Finally, a fair financial package including wages that keep up with cost of living and tuition inflation, health benefits that keep up with rising medical expenses, tuition assistance for a small group of unfunded students, and adjustments to the guaranteed funding package that bring our members closer to the U of T’s own published estimates of the minimum funding necessary to survive in Toronto.
Until recently union demands didn’t have that “gimme, gimme, gimme” quality unions bargaining can sometimes have; their requests were practical and beneficial. But this didn’t last very long. At some point a disgruntled TA claimed that the $36.50 per hour wages for a part-time job put TAs near the poverty line. The image of the TA fighting for the good of the students as well as themselves quickly became the TA knocking on the university’s doors with an outstretched hand. Looking past this seemingly ridiculous claim of poverty to see the merit of the other requests and feel some sympathy for the plight of the TA (while dining on Kraft Dinner for the third night in a row) is difficult for the average, minimum wage earning, “poor” undergrad student.
Why we’ll never be York (allegedly)
At the undergrad town hall held on January 14 the union and student government reps present promised that U of T would not find itself in York’s current predicament. These reps repeatedly cited Angela Hildyard, VP Human Resources and Equity as guaranteeing that our university will not close it doors during a strike.
CUPE 3903, the union representing contract faculty and TAs at York, has been without a contract since the spring 2008 and is now preparing to enter a third month of strike. The deadlock in bargaining between the university administration and union has put the education of thousands on hold and the union is adamantly against binding arbitration. With an entire year nearly lost for York students, not even the faintest glimmer of an agreement is in sight.
The Path to Strike
- Contract ends leaving union members floating in limbo when it comes to their benefits, wages, job security, etc.
- Collective bargaining begins. This begins the attempts to create a new contract stipulating requirements and benefits for employees. If and when this fails proceed to the next step.
- Union coordinates a strike vote. The strike vote provides a little motivation to come to an agreement, and quickly.
- Collective bargaining continues now with the added incentive of the strike mandate looming. Should the bargaining unit and admin fail to reach an agreement, they can apply for a third party facilitator.
- Conciliation with a facilitator is an optional and last ditch attempt to avoid strike. If new contract terms are still not agreed on at this point the union is in a legal position to take action. That means…
- STRIKE!
The plight of the TA is a compelling one. The CUPE representatives at the town hall stressed the importance of student support to apply pressure to the university. Student voices are needed in order to avoid the strike and come to a peaceable agreement sooner rather than later. Maintain your U of T pride by taking a few moments before your next trip to Robarts to visit cupe3902.org or utsu.ca for more information.


January 22nd, 2009 at 10:04 am
I am a reluctant member of 3092, and would refuse to walk the picket line in the event of a strike. From where I sit, CUPE 3092 only wants to divide grad students into “haves” (ie. members of the union and funded cohort) and “have-nots” (those without funding/positions). As a result, many of the things they have been working for over the years attempts to reduce the benefits given to all grad students via GSU in favour of increased benefits for their members. Their efforts and demonstrations are always misplaced and misdirected, ignoring the fiscal reality that begins at Queen’s Park, and ends in confrontation at Simcoe Hall. Militancy among students breeds militancy and force among the administration, and Naylor will not let himself appear to be weak. Therefore, the only winning strategy is collaboration, not so-called negotiation, bargaining and threats.
CUPE provides horrible guidance for how we can resolve the serious issues facing the campus, including those of students, faculty and staff collectively. Get rid of CUPE. Establish a new conversation with the administration. Bring in some of our best faculty and grad student experts on collaboration, high-performance teams, alternative forms of management, transformational leadership, economics, and human psychology. We don’t need the industrial age mentality of CUPE. We need enlightened, 21st century vision and innovation.
January 27th, 2009 at 5:35 pm
[...] https://blogut.ca/2009/01/20/strike-wars/ [...]
January 29th, 2009 at 11:13 pm
“The CUPE representatives at the town hall stressed the importance of student support to apply pressure to the university. Student voices are needed in order to avoid the strike and come to a peaceable agreement sooner rather than later.”
As a York student, that is the same crap 3903 tried to unload on us.
Pressure the university my ass. Many York students did pressure the university, but ALSO pressured the Provincial Government.
Undergrads: don’t turn into CUPE puppets and do their bidding for them
June 29th, 2009 at 10:52 am
Aren’t sick days for when you are sick?
what about UI? if one has a secure job or your business is stable we don’t ask for our taxes back.
ITS CALLED CIVILIZATION.
GET BACK TO WORK YOU ARROGANT SELFISH OVERPAID BUNCH!